Safe communities prevent ‘accidental’ injuries

Safe communities prevent ‘accidental’ injuries

Dr. Trevor Hancock

7 August 2017

699 words

Two weeks ago I pointed out that most injuries are unintentional. The BC Injury Research and Prevention Unit notes that in the five year period 2010 to 2014 the main forms of unintentional injury – falls, unintentional poisoning and transport-related deaths – accounted for more than 6 in 10 of all deaths due to injury in BC and more than two-thirds of acute hospitalisation for injury in 2013/14.

Of these the most important are falls, which have been responsible for about 600 deaths annually in recent years in BC and account for more than half of acute hospitalisation for injury. Overall, the costs of falls in 2010 was $1.2 billion, about one third of the total costs of all injuries in BC, with about half of that due to direct health care costs.

Falls are the leading cause of injury hospitalisation for every age group except under age 1. Most of these falls, and most of the costs, occur among older adults, accounting for about half of the health care cost of all falls. But we shouldn’t ignore the other half of falls in those under age 65.

A Statistics Canada report based on the 2009/10 Canadian Community Health Survey noted that one-third of all self-reported injuries, many of which are falls, “occurred during participation in some type of sports or exercise” and this was the case in two-thirds of those aged 12 to 19. Among adults, work injuries are also an important factor; a 2015 article by Cindy Hunter in OHS Canada noted “more than 40,000 workers get injured annually due to fall accidents”.

Not surprisingly, a great deal of attention has been paid to preventing falls among older adults, given the high rate of falls and the high costs. The BCIRPU reports that “each year, one in three BC seniors (age 65+) experience at least one fall”, with the rate being “three times higher for seniors who live in institutional/residential facilities”. This is an area where BC has shown leadership, with a major effort to address this in seniors’ homes and other facilities.

But in addition to falls in institutions, seniors also fall at home and out in the community; a Statistics Canada report based on the 2009/10 Canadian Community Health Survey noted that “everyday activities like household chores and walking accounted for over half of their injuries”. A 2012 review of the evidence from around the world found several effective fall prevention strategies. These included group and home-based exercise programs and interventions to improve home safety, with some evidence for reviewing medications and gradually withdrawing some forms of psychotropic medicines.

In the UK, Help the Aged has focused on poorly maintained pavements, noting that “More than 2,300 older people fall on broken pavements every day”. Noting that municipal governments have reserve funds to pay for claims, they make the reasonable suggestion that “some of the funds councils hold in legal and compensation reserves should be spent on pavement repairs rather than compensation claims”.

One of my favourite stories about community injury prevention, which I came across many years ago, came from a small hospital in Wales. Recognising that falls in the home were a costly problem for the hospital, they very wisely decided to send their hospital carpenter out to fix seniors’ homes, which reduced the number of falls. Perhaps our health authorities should consider this.

We have often treated falls as ‘accidents’, but in the world of injury prevention, they are not seen that way; there is almost always a preventable human factor at the root of the problem. But there is a very wide range of falls, and they vary a great deal by age, so there are no simple solutions, no quick fixes or univesal approach. It might be said that it takes a whole community to prevent ‘accidents’; homes, schools, workplaces, sports organisations, health care facilities and many others.

One common factor, however – and one that is a significant contributor to all forms of injury – is alcohol use. So a centrepiece of any community injury prevention initiative should be improved control on the availability and price of alcohol, as well as on responsible use. I shall turn to this topic next week.

© Trevor Hancock, 2017



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s